Big Win Sets Up Democrats To Intensify Probe of Trump’s Obamacare Purge

Big Win Sets Up Democrats To Intensify Probe of Trump’s Obamacare Purge

A week before the midterm elections, a dozen Democratic senators sent harshly critical letters to 10 health insurance company CEOs.

Why, the letters asked, had those insurers cooperated with what they called a “potentially unlawful” Trump administration effort that resulted in the rapid cancellation of coverage for 760,000 Affordable Care Act enrollees in late August?

Then came the Democrats’ stunning electoral sweep that, come January, will put them in control of both the House and Senate. The power shift lends new weight to the insurance investigation, led by Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, who is expected to chair the powerful Finance Committee starting next year, and independent Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who is expected to chair the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee.

“Some insurers might view this inquiry as more high-stakes than before given that Democrats will have the power to subpoena documents, hold hearings, and otherwise investigate perceived abuses or missteps,” said Katie Keith, a director of Georgetown University’s Center for Health Policy and the Law.

“Senator Wyden will continue investigating the secret arrangement between corporate interests and the Trump administration that has deprived Americans of their health care,” Wyden spokesperson Taylor Harvey said in an email. “Senate Democrats will use every tool at their disposal to get answers.”

New Oversight Muscle

For months, the administration has promoted the idea that fraud is rampant in government health programs — from the ACA to Medicaid and hospice — and that the Republican Party is the one to thwart it. The White House and some GOP candidates used this talking point to try to counter Democrats’ campaign messages about affordability.

The Trump administration’s anti-fraud efforts are ongoing. The August cancellations are part of a larger initiative by the administration to remove from Obamacare plans people who have other coverage and more strictly scrutinize the information people provide to qualify for premium subsidies. Courts blocked some of the administration’s new rules, including heightened income verification for certain low-income enrollees and a moratorium that would have kept up to 19,000 new agents from helping people sign up during the current annual open enrollment period. Ongoing, however, is scrutiny of an additional 419,000 ACA enrollments in a second phase of the cancellation operation.

Also, new Trump administration requirements compel some people signing up during open enrollment to undergo additional online identity proofing. Insurers were sent guidance in October asking them to look for suspicious patterns among agents and brokers and take action, including cutting commissions, if they found problems. It’s unclear if any insurers have taken those voluntary steps.

The letters from the Democratic senators to insurers provide a look at what the new majority could pursue in its ongoing inquiry into the administration’s ACA actions.

Were proper procedures followed for removing people? How many legitimate enrollees were kicked off the rolls? Did the criteria used to target those enrollments — lack of Social Security number or other key data, not having used medical coverage, a full subsidy without a response to outreach efforts — serve as reliable proxies for determining fraud?

“The tone of these letters underscores just how much of a black box this process was,” said Keith at Georgetown.

Administration officials, however, have defended the cancellation effort.

At an Oct. 14 press conference, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Mehmet Oz was asked about the initial round of cancellations in late August.

“That is fraud, we believe,” Oz said. “That is insurance brokers creating, manufacturing accounts without putting Social Security numbers in and has resulted, we have already determined, in 760,000 phantom accounts that we can’t even get in touch with. We call, we write, we send carrier pigeons — like, no one answers.”

After some of their executives were grilled early in the year over rising healthcare costs, the insurers were given until Nov. 6 to respond to 28 questions from the senators about the cancellation effort, which began in June when they were asked to try to reach more than a million enrollees the administration targeted as suspicious. They handed back to CMS the names of policyholders who did not respond to emails, phone calls, or letters within 30 days.

The senators sent letters to Elevance Health, Cigna, Oscar Health, AmeriHealth Caritas, Centene, Florida Blue, Health Care Service Corporation, Imperial Insurance Companies, Molina Healthcare, and UnitedHealthcare.

By Nov. 10, Harvey in Wyden’s office reported “varying levels of responsiveness” from the insurers.

What Happens Next?

Few dispute that there are problems with improper ACA enrollment. This category includes, the administration says, sign-ups with missing or incorrect data; people who fudge their income estimates to get subsidies; “phantom” enrollees, meaning people who either don’t exist or don’t know they have coverage; and those signed up by rogue call centers or agents to garner commissions.

But there are questions about the relative scale of those problems and the steps by regulators to thwart them.

“The question is whether they overreached and set up a situation that led to many people who are eligible losing their coverage,” said Chip Kahn, a visiting fellow at KFF, a health information nonprofit that includes KFF Health News, and the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank. “They will be pushed hard by the new Congress to come up with the goods in terms of making it crystal clear what’s been done, who has been dropped.” Kahn is also the former president and CEO of the Federation of American Hospitals, a trade association of for-profit hospitals.

The Democratic senators left no doubt about where they stand, saying in their letters that “Republicans are weaponizing fraud falsehoods in order to undercut the ACA Marketplace and kick even more Americans off their health care.”

But Democrats will face limits if they try to interfere with the purge.

“Because the cancellation of ACA policies came via executive authority from the Trump administration rather than legislation, they cannot stop the administration from invoking fraud to cancel ACA policies — unless they can find a legislative solution that can survive a presidential veto or is part of a broader budget agreement,” said Jonathan Oberlander, who teaches health policy at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill.

Democrats have said they will move quickly to try to restore the more generous ACA subsidies that expired at the end of 2025, an effort that will face headwinds. But even a failed attempt might play politically with voters as a move to address affordability concerns. The subsidies were designed to make ACA premiums more affordable.

Marketplace enrollment for 2026 is about 19 million people, down sharply from nearly 22 million in 2025.

Conservative policy groups maintain that the additional subsidies, put in place during the covid era, fueled fraud by allowing many more people to qualify for fully subsidized plans and encouraging them to fudge income estimates to qualify for the largest credits. Large subsidies that reduced monthly premium payments to $0, they argue, also provided cover for unauthorized sign-ups by rogue brokers.

“If the subsidies go up and there are more people in zero-premium plans, then absolutely there will be more fraud,” said Brian Blase, president of the conservative Paragon Health Institute, whose reports assert widespread improper enrollments, sometimes basing that on data it says shows that a growing percentage of enrollees don’t use their insurance.

He’s critical of the Democrats’ letter and expects Congress will ultimately conclude that the administration’s cancellation effort included enough checks to ensure that legitimate enrollees were not caught up or, if they were, could be reinstated.

Very few people — fewer than 0.01% of those purged — have contacted the federal marketplace to request reinstatement, the CMS press office said in an unsigned email to KFF Health News. The agency has not released further details about the cancellations, including whether everyone who lost coverage is aware.

Blase is convinced that, eventually, “the Democrats will realize it was commonsense good governance and move on to something else.”

KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF.
This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Céline Gounder, KFF Health News’ editor-at-large for public health, discussed the resurgence of measles on NPR’s Morning Edition on Nov. 17. Click here to hear Gounder on Morning Edition. KFF Health News Montana correspondent Katheryn Houghton talked about the closures of pediatric intensive care units on Montana Public Radio on Nov. 16.
Congressional Democrats are demanding answers and more transparency from the Trump administration after a nine-day delay of annual awards from a $50 billion fund meant to improve healthcare for rural Americans. Saying rural care is “in an acute state of crisis,” 18 members of Congress sent a letter to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Mehmet Oz late Thursday. The letter pointed to what it called “an alarming lack of public transparency” and said the fund “lacks sufficient guardrails to protect rural hospitals at greatest risk of closure.”
A week before the midterm elections, a dozen Democratic senators sent harshly critical letters to 10 health insurance company CEOs. Why, the letters asked, had those insurers cooperated with what they called a “potentially unlawful” Trump administration effort that resulted in the rapid cancellation of coverage for 760,000 Affordable Care Act enrollees in late August?
With all the jargon, the price tags, and having to guess your income and health needs for the year ahead, it’s no wonder first-time shoppers can feel lost when choosing a health plan. But there’s free help out there if you know where to look. HealthQ host Blake Farmer joined WAMU’s Health Hub on Nov. 18 to share some helpful tips for first-time shoppers navigating the Obamacare marketplace.
The KFF Health News Minute is available every Thursday via direct download or the RSS feed. Nov. 19 Briah [BREE-ah] Lumpkins [LUMP-kinz] reads the week’s news: Signing up for Obamacare can be complicated, but an “independent assister” can help. Plus, how gun owners facing dementia can stay safe as they experience cognitive decline. Your browser does not support the audio element. Can’t see the audio player? Visit kffhealthnews.org to listen. Nov. 12
Letters to the Editor is a periodic feature. We welcome all comments and will publish a selection. We edit for length and clarity and require full names. Reader Recipe Exchange
Until recently, economic researchers were cheering an encouraging trend: Older Americans were staying in the labor force longer and waiting longer to claim their Social Security benefits, aiming to enhance their financial stability in retirement. Not everyone, of course. Despite financial advisers’ counsel and economists’ hopes, most people still claim their benefits before reaching their designated full retirement age, though that usually means lower monthly payments for life. Early claimers might hit an unexpected financial crunch, as Alan Turner did when he lost his job as a museum exhibit...
The Trump administration has approved two states’ requests to expand Medicaid to cover Native American traditional healing practices, even as it prepares to enforce rules that are expected to drop millions of people from the government health insurance program. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced in September that the federal agency had approved traditional healing programs for Utah and Maine. The agency did so through waivers, which give a state permission to pay for certain programs that normally fall outside of Medicaid’s rules. The move increased to six the...
ST. LOUIS — The teen’s hospital stay began in Room 3005. The room didn’t feel like home at first. Back then, Jaloni didn’t have posters on the wall or snacks on the shelf, and he hadn’t learned about the morgue yet. He just wanted to survive. Fresh gunshot wounds filled the 14-year-old’s body with unbearable pain. That first night, Jaloni said, he could barely move. But in his own way, Jaloni could fly. His pain medication was so strong that the teenager said he felt like he was soaring in a dream.
(Maria Fabrizio for WPLN and KFF Health News) Jael Samano’s recent move from Illinois to Wisconsin after college changed a lot of things in her life. It brought a new job as an environmental consultant and a new housing situation — living on her own for the first time. Those were expected changes. But it wasn’t until she saw her therapist, shortly before moving, that she realized how relocating out of state would also change her healthcare. She’d have to find new providers and learn a new health insurance system through her employer.
GREENVILLE, N.C. — When the federal funding ran dry, Diannee Carden Glenn’s options were few. Carden Glenn is the director of ekiM for Change, a volunteer-run public health organization that works to prevent overdoses in Greenville and surrounding rural communities. For much of the past decade, she relied on funding from the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration to buy drug test strips, used to check for contaminants in the street-drug supply.
LĪHUʻE, Hawaiʻi — Dylan Lawton realized something was wrong when he struggled to use his right leg to hit the brakes while driving. Within a matter of hours, scans showed the third-year medical student had a brain tumor. But the island of Kauaʻi, where he was completing his clinical rotation, has no neurosurgeons. So Lawton was medically evacuated on a plane to Straub Benioff Medical Center on O‘ahu, Hawaiʻi’s most populous island. There, the then-27-year-old was diagnosed with a type of lung cancer commonly found in nonsmokers, which was stage 4 and had spread to his brain.
Early in her election-night victory speech, Democrat Keisha Lance Bottoms, Georgia’s next governor, alluded to one of her main campaign promises: granting more low-income adults access to government health insurance. “This win is for the caregiver who can’t afford healthcare and needs Georgia to finally expand Medicaid,” she told a crowd of cheering supporters. The national Democratic landslide that will give the party control of Congress will also sweep Bottoms and other Democratic gubernatorial candidates into office in a handful of states that have for years resisted fully expanding...
The U.S. has officially lost its status as a country where measles is eliminated, a public health triumph secured a quarter century ago. Researchers with direct knowledge of the deliberations on the country’s status told KFF Health News that the Pan American Health Organization reached the conclusion this week: Measles has reestablished regular transmission in the country. PAHO had planned a public announcement on Nov. 17. In public health parlance, measles elimination depends on a country’s sporadic outbreaks ending within a year. That’s no longer happening in the United States.
The U.S. has officially lost its status as a country where measles is eliminated, a public health triumph secured a quarter century ago. On Nov. 17, the Pan American Health Organization announced that measles has reestablished regular transmission in the country. In public health parlance, measles elimination depends on a country’s sporadic outbreaks ending within a year. That’s no longer happening in the U.S. “We are seeing a resurgence of a disease our region worked so hard to eliminate,” PAHO director Jarbas Barbosa said at a press briefing, days after researchers with direct knowledge of...
KFF Health News senior correspondent Julie Appleby joined WBUR’s Here & Now on Nov. 11 to discuss how a fraud crackdown is making Affordable Care Act open enrollment more difficult. Appleby also discussed the expected rise in premiums, deductibles, and copays for Medicare and employer-based healthcare plans on WVXU’s Cincinnati Edition on Nov. 9.
HILLSBORO, N.D. — The Kritzberger family has farmed in the Red River Valley for more than a century. They once had livestock. Now they grow sugar beets, soybeans, and grains. Like many farmers, they labor to balance the books. “We’re in an incredible amount of debt,” Ang Kritzberger said as she walked the farm on a recent fall morning. For the past 10 years, the Kritzbergers have had another worry. Their daughter Nina has Type 1 diabetes. That’s landed the family in a national debate about how to protect patients from high insulin costs. Nina was diagnosed when she was 7. “I slept by her...
CHEROKEE, N.C. — Two months before the deadline to implement new Medicaid work requirements, states had yet to receive detailed guidance from federal health officials on how to exclude Native Americans from those rules, leading to a patchwork of eligibility checks that pose challenges for qualified enrollees trying to keep their health insurance.
KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF. This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF. This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

 

DISCLAIMER: The information found on this Web Site is dynamic and subject to change. Please use the "CONTACT US" section of the Web Site to submit any questions or comments.